Gold 104.3

Now Playing:

Listen on

INSANE Titanic Theory Would Make The Film EVEN MORE Tragic

If you saw Titanic and sobbed along, you’re definitely not alone.

However, a new theory will definitely make Jack and Rose’s story even more heartbreaking for you.

Get the tissues ready…

A reddit user shares the theory that Jack actually wasn’t real. He was simply a figment of Rose’s imagination. In other words, someone she conjured up to save her from the life she didn’t want.


This is how they figure it; she first meets Jack when she's thinking about committing suicide because she feels trapped in an engagement with a man she doesn’t love.


During this, she imagines a man who is the opposite of fiancé Cal in every way: kind, spontaneous, noble, selfless, and full of life.

Then Jack Dawson appears! Rose believes Jack is real because she’s desperate to break free from her mother, and from Cal. Jack convinces her to "break free to stay alive," thereby voicing her own subconscious, and making her stronger and braver.


Then, when the ship sinks, the famous door scene occurs, where Rose survives and Jack dies - because according to the theory, he was never real anyway. Rose tells him she’ll ‘never let go’, and then lets him drift into the murky waters.


The idea behind it being he could never get out anyway - but she’ll take with her the lessons of survival he taught her.

The biggest real ‘evidence’ of this theory is the fact that the bearded dude from the excavation crew says that there was never any record of Jack on the passenger list, though, many would argue it’s because he won tickets only a few minutes before the ship sailed.

The other reason it may not be true is because you see Jack interacting with lots of other people during the movie, although, as the movie is entirely from Rose’s perspective, she may just be an unreliable narrator.

But we are choosing to believe he WAS real and they were reunited in heaven and all was well and good!


Share this: